Willa Davis is eigenares van een dierenwinkel in San Francisco. Tien jaar na haar middelbare schooltijd komt haar voormalige klasgenoot Keane Winters haar winkel binnen met de kat van zijn tante.
Nee, helaas is The Trouble with Mistletoe nog niet beschikbaar op Netflix in Nederland.
| Camera | Patrice Lucien Cochet | Director of Photography |
| Editing | Margaret Goodspeed | Editor |
| Production | Jina Panebianco | Executive Producer |
| Art | Robert Wise | Production Design |
| Production | Ashley Sinn | Unit Production Manager |
| Costume & Make-Up | Jill Paz | Makeup Artist |
| Production | Durey Shevar | Producer |
| Sound | Silvio Amato | Music |
| Editing | Julian Habib | Editor |
| Production | Tosca Musk | Executive Producer |
| Writing | Joany Kane | Writer |
| Production | Joany Kane | Executive Producer |
| Art | Traci Hays | Art Direction |
| Art | Mindy Smith | Set Decoration |
| Production | Jill Shalvis | Executive Producer |
| Directing | Ashley Avis | Director |
| Writing | Jill Shalvis | Novel |
