Noah reist via een magisch fotohokje terug in de tijd om de avond waarop hij Avery ontmoette, steeds opnieuw te beleven. Zo hoopt hij haar voor zich te winnen.
Ja! de film When We First Met is nu beschikbaar om te kijken op Netflix in Nederland.
| Production | Steve Eddy | Executive Producer |
| Sound | Tracy McKnight | Music Supervisor |
| Costume & Make-Up | Jessica Carpenter | Costume Supervisor |
| Directing | Mike De La Vina | Second Assistant Director |
| Production | James McGough | Executive Producer |
| Crew | Rob Mars | Stunt Coordinator |
| Production | Peter Pastorelli | Unit Production Manager |
| Directing | Paul B. Uddo | First Assistant Director |
| Sound | Rachel Grissom | Sound Mixer |
| Costume & Make-Up | Marcos Gonzalez | Assistant Hairstylist |
| Sound | Allan Zaleski | Sound Designer |
| Directing | Gerson Paz | Second Second Assistant Director |
| Sound | Tony Volante | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
| Costume & Make-Up | Adam Gaeta | Hair Department Head |
| Costume & Make-Up | Aimee Stuit | Makeup Department Head |
| Crew | Jonathan Ferrantelli | Post Production Supervisor |
| Sound | Allan Zaleski | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
| Costume & Make-Up | Paige Reeves | Assistant Makeup Artist |
| Sound | Allan Zaleski | Supervising Sound Editor |
| Directing | Sam Sullivan | Script Supervisor |
| Writing | John Whittington | Writer |
| Directing | Ari Sandel | Director |
| Production | Peter Pastorelli | Executive Producer |
| Camera | David Hennings | Director of Photography |
| Production | Mary Viola | Producer |
| Art | Michelle C. Harmon | Art Direction |
| Editing | Jeffrey Wolf | Editor |
| Art | Gae S. Buckley | Production Design |
| Production | Eyde Belasco | Casting |
| Production | Michelle Knudsen | Producer |
| Production | Adam Saunders | Producer |
| Production | Adam Devine | Executive Producer |
| Production | Eddie Rubin | Line Producer |
| Production | Daniella Kahane | Executive Producer |
| Sound | Eric V. Hachikian | Music |
| Production | Mason Novick | Producer |
| Production | Benji Kohn | Executive Producer |
| Production | Steven Bello | Executive Producer |
| Production | Bingo Gubelmann | Executive Producer |
| Art | Gretchen Gattuso | Set Decoration |
| Production | Danny Zamost | Executive Producer |
| Costume & Make-Up | Meagan McLaughlin | Costume Design |
| Production | McG | Producer |
| Crew | Mallory Thompson | Stunt Double |
| Editing | Erik Choquette | Color Assistant |
