Noah heeft de perfecte eerste nacht met het meisje van zijn dromen beleefd, maar tot zijn ongenoegen is hij vervolgens in de friendzone beland. De daaropvolgende jaren blijft Noah zich afvragen wat er die avond verkeerd is gegaan. Wanneer onverwacht de mogelijkheid zich voordoet om terug in de tijd te reizen besluit Noah de bewuste avond telkens her te beleven om te achterhalen wat er fout ging en haar alsnog voor zich te winnen.
Ja! de film When We First Met is nu beschikbaar om te kijken op Netflix in Nederland.
| Writing | John Whittington | Writer |
| Directing | Ari Sandel | Director |
| Production | Daniella Kahane | Executive Producer |
| Production | Michelle Knudsen | Producer |
| Production | Eyde Belasco | Casting |
| Production | McG | Producer |
| Sound | Eric V. Hachikian | Music |
| Art | Michelle C. Harmon | Art Direction |
| Art | Gretchen Gattuso | Set Decoration |
| Production | Adam Saunders | Producer |
| Production | Danny Zamost | Executive Producer |
| Art | Gae S. Buckley | Production Design |
| Production | Adam Devine | Executive Producer |
| Production | Mason Novick | Producer |
| Production | Steven Bello | Executive Producer |
| Production | Peter Pastorelli | Executive Producer |
| Production | Mary Viola | Producer |
| Production | Bingo Gubelmann | Executive Producer |
| Costume & Make-Up | Meagan McLaughlin | Costume Design |
| Production | Benji Kohn | Executive Producer |
| Camera | David Hennings | Director of Photography |
| Editing | Jeffrey Wolf | Editor |
| Production | Eddie Rubin | Line Producer |
| Production | Steve Eddy | Executive Producer |
| Production | James McGough | Executive Producer |
| Sound | Tracy McKnight | Music Supervisor |
| Production | Peter Pastorelli | Unit Production Manager |
| Directing | Paul B. Uddo | First Assistant Director |
| Directing | Mike De La Vina | Second Assistant Director |
| Crew | Rob Mars | Stunt Coordinator |
| Costume & Make-Up | Jessica Carpenter | Costume Supervisor |
| Costume & Make-Up | Aimee Stuit | Makeup Department Head |
| Costume & Make-Up | Paige Reeves | Assistant Makeup Artist |
| Costume & Make-Up | Adam Gaeta | Hair Department Head |
| Costume & Make-Up | Marcos Gonzalez | Assistant Hairstylist |
| Directing | Sam Sullivan | Script Supervisor |
| Sound | Rachel Grissom | Sound Mixer |
| Directing | Gerson Paz | Second Second Assistant Director |
| Crew | Jonathan Ferrantelli | Post Production Supervisor |
| Sound | Allan Zaleski | Supervising Sound Editor |
| Sound | Allan Zaleski | Sound Designer |
| Sound | Tony Volante | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
| Sound | Allan Zaleski | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
| Crew | Mallory Thompson | Stunt Double |
