Vince Rizzo is een gevangenisbewaarder in de Bronx. Op een dag ontdekt hij dat zijn buitenechtelijke relatie twintig jaar geleden een zoon op de wereld heeft gezet, de gevangene Tony Nardella. Vince besluit zijn zoon te beschermen, en hem op te nemen in de familie. Het grote struikelblok is het feit dat Vince 20 jaar zwijgzaamheid over zijn slippertje nu moet doorbreken, of hij zal moeten liegen over de ware identiteit van Tony.
Nee, helaas is City Island nog niet beschikbaar op Netflix in Nederland.
| Directing | Raymond De Felitta | Director |
| Writing | Raymond De Felitta | Writer |
| Production | Meredith Tucker | Casting |
| Camera | Vanja Cernjul | Director of Photography |
| Production | Lucia Seabra | Executive Producer |
| Production | Luis de Val | Co-Executive Producer |
| Production | Rene Garcia | Co-Executive Producer |
| Production | Maria Teresa Arida | Executive Producer |
| Costume & Make-Up | Tere Duncan | Costume Design |
| Production | Michael Roban | Executive Producer |
| Production | Edward Walson | Co-Executive Producer |
| Production | Zachary Matz | Producer |
| Production | Raymond De Felitta | Producer |
| Production | Grzegorz Hajdarowicz | Executive Producer |
| Production | Edward Easton | Co-Executive Producer |
| Editing | David Leonard | Editor |
| Production | Andy García | Producer |
| Production | Sheila Jaffe | Casting |
| Production | William J. Bresnan | Co-Executive Producer |
| Production | Milutin G. Gatsby | Executive Producer |
| Sound | Jan A. P. Kaczmarek | Original Music Composer |
| Art | Franckie Diago | Production Design |
| Production | Lauren Versel | Producer |
| Production | Antonio Gijon | Co-Executive Producer |
| Production | Ged Dickersin | Unit Production Manager |
| Directing | Eric Henriquez | First Assistant Director |
| Production | Andrew Saxe | Production Supervisor |
| Camera | Phillip V. Caruso | Still Photographer |
| Art | Sorangel Fersobe | Art Direction |
| Art | Kelley Burney | Set Decoration |
| Art | Daniel Fisher | Property Master |
| Art | Jonathan Huggins | Leadman |
| Art | Alexis Weiss | Assistant Property Master |
| Lighting | Greg Quinlan | Gaffer |
| Camera | Brendan Quinlan | Key Grip |
| Camera | Joe Sarao | Best Boy Grip |
| Camera | Kevin Lowry | Dolly Grip |
| Production | Shannon Causey | Location Manager |
| Costume & Make-Up | Pamela May | Key Hair Stylist |
| Costume & Make-Up | Sharon Ilson | Key Makeup Artist |
| Costume & Make-Up | Jorjee Douglass | Makeup Artist |
| Directing | Rachel Connors | Script Supervisor |
| Directing | Sharon Watt | Script Supervisor |
| Crew | Jessica Drake | Dialect Coach |
| Sound | Jan McLaughlin | Sound Mixer |
| Sound | Vince Reed Camuto | Boom Operator |
| Crew | Manny Siverio | Stunt Coordinator |
| Costume & Make-Up | Rabiah Troncelliti | Assistant Costume Designer |
| Sound | Thomas O'Neil Younkman | Supervising Sound Editor |
| Sound | Gary Coppola | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
| Sound | Brad Sherman | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
